guthrie's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[CHASE.fla]

Hahaha that was unexpected. Nice twist on your usual stuff.

Great animation as always.

[Rush Run Ruin Repeat]

This is really good, but the perspective is really fucking with my brain. Was that intentional? If so, you really accomplished something great.

I really like how relatable this is to my own experiences in writing.

Great job, keep it up!

BuGzY111 responds:

Ah yes you noticed my weakness, perspective is not my strongest.
I know what you mean tho, next time I'll be trying a different approach.
Thanks a lot for the feedback :)

[Thanksgiving Sex Ed.]

Every part of this animation is lazy. You continue to use GoAnimate, causing this massive and awful watermark. The stock props you use in each scene are plain and boring. The rooms you use are empty and unpleasant. Your "animation" of the characters is just as lazy as the rest of the constituent parts of the submission; your models float around the screen, unlike any human I've observed. The way models move are something a toddler would think of. The humor is simply sad, any jokes that could be construed as funny are set aside in favor of childish sex jokes.

Nothing about this is submission is acceptable and I am saddened that this passed judgement.

AnimationOverload responds:

I apologize your intelligence is too low to grasp the educational concepts covered in this video. Perhaps through eating fish or listening to the teachings of Bill Nye the Science Guy, you will someday be wise enough to look past the surface level, and break through to a new horizon.

[Music : Foamy The Squirrel]

This hardly qualifies as animation. It's simply a few frames of a squirrel with no inbetweens while a rant plays in the background. You've been releasing these rants for over 10 years and this is still the level of work you're doing? Sorry, but I expect a bit more.

The rant is rambling and drawn out. Most of the substance could be distilled to about a paragraph worth of actual talking points.

These types of videos are way less entertaining than a lot of your other animations.

[Clayface - Deep Dark serie]

Incredible.

I think the sound was a little muted, but this was still beautifully done. I love your animation style.

DanielCuervo responds:

thank u a lot! :)

[Red Neck Sex Ed.]

This is nothing more than incredibly lazy work.

You're trying too hard to be offensive and it's really just sad.

AnimationOverload responds:

I'm not trying to offend; I'm trying to educate.

[Terry fold - Chaos Chaos ft. Justin Roiland [Animated music video]]

Brilliantly animated. Glad you're getting the recognition you deserve for this.

[(REUPLOAD) Flash test]

Your animation was blammed because it's a random collection of extremely short clips which have no logical progression. The music doesn't match anything happening in the video. You're drawing stick figures. Videos like this get blammed all the time, nobody is harassing you. Now because you uploaded the video again without any changes made it will likely be removed by a mod.

The portal exists to filter out these kinds of submissions.

TSwany responds:

I just wanted to share my attempts at animation with the world. On youtube, new videos don't reach the front page unlike here, so this was my only hope. Finding out it was blammed the next morning really made me upset, because i felt like no one liked my animation. I'm still learning, I just got adobe animate, so it's obvious it wasn't that good, but I don't feel like it deserves to be blammed.

[First animation Using flash]

Not bad!

Your animation and drawing skill shows a lot of promise.

In the future I would suggest some audio processing, a better microphone, and definitely speaking more clearly when you're recording your voice. Also check out the voice acting forum in the BBS if you're looking for some voice actors.

Keep it up and I'm excited to see what you come out with next!

[GorillazAshProgress]

The art is very impressive but this really is the bare minimum that's required to be called an animation. This isn't Portal material in my opinion and would be better suited as a collage in the Art Portal.

You're a fantastic artist and I'm interested to see more art from you!

johan86 responds:

Thanks for the review, this was not meant to be art but to show my art in Progress. I will try and not disappoint you next time. My actual artwork was a submission for the Jazza's COTM Style swap.